Eight components of engineering insurance
Engineering insurance is not a single product but a complementary family of covers. Each component addresses different causes of loss and different project or operational phases.
Machinery Breakdown (MB)
- Mechanical internal failure — material fatigue
- Short circuit, arc, overvoltage
- Operator error
- Lubrication failure
- Centrifugal force — fracture
- Wear and tear excluded
Electronic Equipment Insurance (EEI)
- Computer and server systems
- Medical and diagnostic devices
- Measurement, control, SCADA
- Communication systems
- Data media (separate cover)
- Temporary equipment rental costs
Contractors' All Risks (CAR)
- Civil / structural construction projects
- Section I: Contract works damage
- Section II: Contractors' plant & equipment
- Section III: TPL liability
- Defects liability period (DLP)
- Existing structures additional cover
Erection All Risks (EAR)
- Mechanical / electrical installation projects
- Testing & Commissioning Period coverage
- CPE (equipment) cover
- Existing machinery additional cover
- DSU / ALOP linkage
- DLP latent defect
Contractors' Plant & Machinery (CPM)
- Excavators, cranes, dozers, backhoes
- Concrete pumps, mixers
- Generators, compressors
- Coverage across different sites
- Theft cover
- Independent of CAR Section II
Boiler & Pressure Vessel
- Boiler explosion — physical damage
- Third-party bodily injury
- Pressure vessel, piping system
- Periodic inspection compliance
- Mandatory insurance coverage
- Production loss linkage
Machinery Breakdown Loss of Profits (MLOP)
- Revenue loss linked to MB damage
- Continuing fixed costs
- Waiting period
- Indemnity Period
- Critical equipment procurement time basis
- Coordinated with MB policy
Delay in Start-Up / Advanced Loss of Profits (DSU/ALOP)
- Delay linked to CAR/EAR damage
- Lost revenue from delayed start-up date
- Project financing interest cost
- Cannot be activated independently
- Waiting period is critical
- May be required by project lender
Core technical boundaries: covered vs excluded
The most critical concept in engineering insurance is this: the policy covers sudden and accidental damage. Gradual deterioration, wear and tear or damage resulting from maintenance failure occurring over time is excluded. This boundary is one of the most frequently disputed topics in loss cases.
Coverage Boundaries — Sudden Damage vs Gradual Deterioration
Internal vs External Cause: Coverage Boundary
MB insurance covers primarily internally caused failures — the machine breaking down from its own internal cause. External events such as fire, water damage or storm fall under the property/fire policy. The boundary point matters:
- Motor burnout caused by external fire → property/fire policy (externally caused event)
- Motor burnout from internal short circuit → MB policy (internally caused failure)
- Clarifying the boundary between the two policies is critical for rapid claims settlement in large loss scenarios.
Defective Design, Defective Materials and Workmanship: coverage boundaries
The LEG clauses in construction (CAR/EAR) policies have an equivalent distinction in the operating MB policy: defective design/materials/workmanship in themselves are excluded, but damage caused by that defect to other sound parts may be covered.
Defective Design / Materials / Workmanship — Coverage Distinction
The wording formulation on this point is decisive in large loss claims
Excluded — The Defective Part Itself
- The gearbox gear set that was incorrectly designed
- Pump impeller manufactured from unsuitable material
- Shaft prone to damage due to incorrect assembly
- Structural component with crack from defective manufacture
- Part that fails to meet performance specs but has no physical damage
Covered — Surroundings Affected by the Defect
- Gearbox housing damaged by the breakage of the defective gear set
- Pump casing damage caused by impeller fracture
- Bearings and crankcase damaged by defective shaft failure
- Building damage from structural component crack (CAR)
- Surrounding fire damage triggered by the defective part
Policy wording matters: Some policies use a 'DE clause' that only excludes the defective part itself and covers surrounding damage. Others exclude all damage caused by the defective design. This formulation must be carefully read and negotiated before the policy incepts.
Maintenance deficiency and its effect on claims
Failure to carry out maintenance in accordance with manufacturer instructions directly affects loss causation. Evidence of maintenance deficiency can give the insurer grounds for claim rejection or reduction. However:
- Even if maintenance deficiency is a precondition, the claim may still be valid — though contested — if the damage occurred suddenly.
- Keeping complete maintenance records facilitates both claims management and renewal premium negotiations.
- The underwriter requests the maintenance plan and latest service reports at the submission stage; these form the basis of the risk assessment.
Machinery breakdown vs electronic equipment insurance
MB and EEI are similar but address different equipment categories. The scope of the two policies can sometimes overlap; defining the correct boundary is important.
MB — Machinery Breakdown
- Production machinery — lathes, presses, milling machines
- Electric motors, pumps, compressors
- Heating and cooling systems — HVAC
- Generators and power units
- Cranes, conveyors, loading equipment
- Turbines, gas engines
- Cover: internal mechanical/electrical failure
- External damage → property/fire policy
EEI — Electronic Equipment Insurance
- Computer and server systems
- Medical imaging and diagnostic devices
- SCADA, PLC, measurement instruments
- Communication and broadcast systems
- Security and CCTV systems
- Electronic safes and payment systems
- Cover: internal failure + external damage (water, impact)
- Data media and extra expense additional covers
Where EEI extends beyond MB
- External damage coverage: EEI goes beyond MB to also cover externally caused damage — water damage, spillage, impact, theft (subject to policy wording).
- Portable equipment: Laptops, tablets, portable measurement instruments — MB generally covers fixed equipment; EEI can extend to these portable categories.
- Data media: Damage to storage media and data reconstruction costs can be structured as an additional cover within EEI.
- Extra expense: Cost of temporary equipment rental or outsourcing services as a replacement for the damaged system.
Contractors' Plant & Machinery (CPM): difference from CAR Section II
CAR Section II covers contractors' plant at the site on a project-specific basis. CPM is an independent, continuous policy for the equipment-owning contractor.
Project-Specific Equipment Cover
Covers contractors' plant used at a specific construction project site on a project-by-project basis. Coverage ends when the project is completed or the equipment leaves the site. Its project-specific structure may be insufficient for contractors operating across multiple sites simultaneously.
Contractor's Equipment — Across Every Site
A continuous policy covering equipment owned by the equipment-owning contractor across different sites. The equipment schedule can be updated during the year; all fleet items are managed under a single policy. Premium is determined by equipment value and intensity of use.
Risks Covered by Both
Accident: overturning, collision, submersion. Fire, explosion. Theft (subject to conditions). Flood/water damage — additional cover. Electrical damage. Operator error. Damage during transportation (subject to policy wording).
Risks Excluded from Coverage
Wear and tear and obsolescence. Routine maintenance costs. Risks overlapping with vehicle insurance (road traffic accident as a vehicle). War and terrorism (additional cover). If equipment is hired, the ownership distinction applies — specific policy wording may be required for hired-in plant.
Boiler and pressure vessel: mandatory insurance and technical obligations
In Türkiye, both compulsory insurance and periodic technical inspection obligations exist for boilers and pressure vessels above certain capacity thresholds. These two requirements complement each other but are administered by different bodies.
Boiler Insurance — Compulsory Insurance
Covers third-party bodily injury and property damage resulting from an explosion. The cover amount must be at least at the minimum limits prescribed by legislation. An operating licence cannot be maintained without insurance; inspection and enforcement authority rests with the Ministry of Labour and Social Security.
Material Damage Cover
Compulsory insurance only covers third-party damage. Separate material damage cover must be obtained for damage to the boiler itself and to surrounding machinery and plant. The material damage premium amount is significant for large boiler installations.
Technical Inspection Compliance
Periodic pressure tests and safety valve checks conducted by accredited inspection bodies. If inspection is not carried out on time or non-conformities are not remedied, both the insurance coverage and the operating licence are put at risk.
Production Loss Risk
Since a major boiler failure can shut down an entire facility, production loss is a significant risk. In addition to boiler insurance, MB-based MLOP or BI insurance should be evaluated. The Indemnity Period must be set according to the procurement time for a replacement boiler.
MLOP and DSU/ALOP: loss of profits and delay coverage
Machinery Breakdown Loss of Profits (MLOP)
MB Loss
For MLOP to apply, a physical machinery failure that qualifies as a compensable loss under the MB policy must first occur.
Waiting Period
MLOP is not paid for the first X days of the outage. Shorter waiting period = higher premium. 24–72 hours in energy facilities; varies for manufacturing plants.
Indemnity Period
Maximum compensation period. The procurement time for critical equipment must determine this period; underestimating it creates a significant coverage gap.
DSU / ALOP — Delay During the Construction Phase
DSU (Delay in Start-Up) or ALOP (Advanced Loss of Profits) covers lost revenue resulting from a project starting later than the planned commissioning date due to a loss covered under the CAR/EAR policy.
- Dependent on CAR/EAR damage: Only delays caused by an insured construction/erection loss are covered. Delays from contractor performance, supply chain issues or design changes are excluded.
- Waiting period / franchise: No payment is made for the first X days of delay resulting from the insured loss.
- Project financing requirement: Lenders may require DSU/ALOP in the loan agreement; the Indemnity Period must cover at least the minimum debt service period.
- Supporting documentation: Project revenue projections, operating costs and financing cost records must be provided to the underwriter for indemnity calculations.
Indemnity Period trap: Procurement time for a large turbine or custom transformer is 18–36 months. If the MLOP or DSU Indemnity Period is set at 12 months and the equipment takes 20 months to procure, the loss in the final 8 months falls outside the indemnity. The Indemnity Period should never be set without accurate knowledge of critical equipment procurement times.
Sum Insured, Replacement Value and Deductible Structure
Sum Insured — basis of valuation
Accurate determination of the sum insured in engineering insurance prevents underinsurance at the time of a claim. The valuation basis differs for each equipment category:
- Machinery and equipment: Replacement Value — the current cost of purchasing the same or equivalent new equipment without depreciation. International market price + installation + freight, not domestic production cost.
- Construction projects (CAR): Total contract value of the completed project + materials + contractors' plant; professional fees separately in some structures.
- Electronic devices (EEI): Replacement Value; current market price of the latest model with equivalent technical specifications. Note the difference in value arising from technological obsolescence.
- CPM: Fair market value of each item of equipment — separate valuation for machines of different ages.
Deductible Structure
Fixed Amount Deductible
The insured bears a predetermined fixed amount for each loss. Acts as a filter against small claims; determined according to the insured's own retention capacity.
Percentage Deductible
The insured bears a specified percentage of the loss amount. This can be a significant sum for large losses; particularly high rates apply to earthquake and flood additional covers.
Per-Equipment Deductible
Separate deductible per item of damaged equipment, not per loss event. Simplifies claims management at large facilities with many items of equipment.
Testing & Commissioning
In EAR policies, higher deductibles may apply to losses during the Testing & Commissioning phase; hot commissioning (fuel-fired operation) is treated differently from cold commissioning.
Serial Loss Deductible
For serial losses from the same manufacturer and model, a separate deductible may apply per unit or a single deductible may be taken as one event; policy wording must be clarified.
MLOP / BI Waiting Period
The deductible in MLOP and DSU policies expressed in time rather than money. The first 24–72 hours or longer business interruption remains uncompensated.
Which engineering policy covers which risk?
In real loss scenarios, which policy responds is sometimes disputed. The table below classifies the most common scenarios by engineering policy type.
| Loss Scenario | MB | EEI | CAR / EAR | CPM | Boiler | MLOP / DSU |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Internal short circuit in production machine → damage | Yes | No | No | No | No | Linked to MB |
| Server room water damage (AC leak) | No | Yes | No | No | No | Linked to EEI |
| Site storm — collapse of incomplete structure | No | No | Yes (CAR) | No | No | DSU linked |
| Excavator overturn — operator error | No | No | CAR Sec.II | Yes | No | No |
| Boiler explosion — damage to adjacent machinery | Surrounding damage | No | No | No | Yes | MB/BI linked |
| Bearing failure → production stopped (3 days) | Yes | No | No | No | No | MLOP active |
| Damage during EAR commissioning post-installation | Not yet in operation | No | Yes (EAR) | No | No | DSU linked |
| SCADA / PLC fire-caused damage | No | Policy wording dependent | No | No | No | Linked to EEI |
| Lightning surge — control board burnout | Policy wording dependent | Yes | No | No | No | Linked to EEI |
| Crane damage — during transfer between sites | No | No | No — off-site | Yes — CPM | No | No |
| Gradual damage due to machinery wear and tear | Excluded — wear & tear | Excluded | Excluded | Excluded | Excluded | Excluded |
| Defective design — gearbox failure and housing damage | Surrounding damage: yes; defective part: no | No | Wording dependent | No | No | Linked to MB |
What Does the Underwriting Submission Require?
The following information and documents must be prepared for the engineering insurance submission to be assessed quickly and accurately. This list also brings risk improvement opportunities to the agenda.
Equipment and Fleet Information
Maintenance and Loss History
Utilisation and Operating Environment
BI Dependency and Risk Structure
Serial Loss risk assessment
For facilities where multiple units of the same manufacturer and model are used, the underwriter makes additional enquiries:
- How many units of each equipment brand/model are present
- How many units would be affected in a mass failure scenario and the PML estimate
- Whether a sublimit will be applied for Serial Loss
- Whether diversification will be undertaken (use of different brands/models)